Is F-Commerce "Fail" Commerce?

Last week we posted a little video parody on the things ecommerce consultants say. One of the tongue-in-cheek examples is “Social media isn’t about driving sales, per se…what do you mean you don’t have a Facebook Store?”

The next day, Bloomberg published an article reminding us that big retailers like JC Penney, Gamestop, Nordstrom and GAP that have shut the doors on their F-stores.

Fail Commerce?

It’s no surprise that embedded stores have faltered. The shopping experience within Facebook is painful compared to regular websites. Who prefers the banner ads, smaller screens, slower page loads, reduced functionality of F-stores? Not to mention, Facebook’s stellar track record with member privacy!

Simply plugging a catalog into a Fan page is not social commerce. It’s just commerce inside a social network.

But Facebook users have not shunned commercial brands. Consumers will Fan / Like brands in social networks in order to “recommend” to friends and to give permission for the brand to interact with their News Feed. The new wave of Facebook Timeline Apps are all about creating experiences that are social and that people want to use personally and share across their network, leveraging the Facebook Open Graph.

At the risk of sounding like an ecommerce consultant all-too-eager to hail the virtues of an unproven platform, let’s look at the social commerce opportunity beyond plug-in storefronts.

Finding the Adjacent Possible in Social Commerce

If you recall, in the digital disruption webinar we did last week (it’s still free to check out), Forrester’s James McQuivey how businesses can become disruptors by finding the adjacent possible, or the intersection of the next most immediate thing that people really want,” and matching it to the next immediate thing that you can provide.

Here are some real-world examples:

Ticketmaster Interactive Seat Map

Ticketmaster’s Timeline app allows fans to share events they are attending with friends, order tickets through the app and receive event suggestions based on their likes and listening habits through Spotify.

Its Interactive Seat Map allows people to see where their friends are sitting at an event. According to Ticketmaster, each share drives $5 in incremental revenue.

Electronic Arts’ Battlefield 3

F-stores don’t have to be catalogs. In fact, they should be anything but your full catalog.

Electronic Arts launched a temporary “pop-up” store within its fan page for pre-orders fo Battlefield 3 along with exclusive gifts like Back to Karkland Expansion Pack, Physical Warfare Pack and Play4free Beret and Gun. Using Facebook as an alternative to a microsite increases the value of being a fan, and makes social sharing seamless. Offering exclusives is a way to reward die-hard fans and deepen the commitment between brand and customer.

EA also created a “Missions” app, which extends the social aspect of the game. Users can build “squads” of their Facebook friends, create events or share videos.

Engagement stats are not too shabby:

20th Century Fox

Box office movies are by nature social products – people attend movies with others and talk about them with friends, and now research and discuss them through social media. The old school way of marketing films was through theater trailers, TV spots and bus shelter posters. 20th Century Fox pulls a 21st century move by creating a Facebook page for it’s Ladies’ Night from which fans could purchase tickets and enter for a chance to win one of 100 copies of the book that inspired the movie.

The studio also created an Event page to which fans could RSVP for the film, and incorporated a group-buy reward system in partnership with Gilt Groupe, SpaFinder and 7 For All Mankind.

These experiences all make more sense within Facebook than on the brand’s website, leveraging the social graph and offering simple transaction selections rather than a copy of the entire catalog.

The examples above are all cases provided by 8thBridge, formerly Alvenda (the company that created the shopping widget that 1-800-Flowers used to embed into Facebook and claim the first in-Facebook transaction in 2009). Misquoted in the Bloomberg article, in response 8thBridge CEO Wade Gerten contributed a guest article to Forbes Magazine, highlighting the results early-adopters of the Open Graph platform have achieved:

“Brands have seen their website traffic increase 50% to 300% from Facebook in just a few months.

This is dramatically more traffic than anything the industry has seen produced by social media up to this point. Certainly, the increased traffic adds immediate tangible value but there is a much bigger opportunity on the horizon.

“Tomorrow’s online shopping experience will look very different than the product catalog-specific experience we have today. The rich intent data available via the Open Graph will enable brands to usher in a new era of ecommerce that is shaped by people and around people.”

It’s not that F-Commerce is a failure, rather the shift is towards bringing social features from Facebook to your commercial website, rather than bringing your store into the social network.

When To Shun F-Commerce

The reason why F-stores are a flop for most, if not all, ecommerce brands is customers were never asking for Facebook storefronts.

If you can’t identify something that your customers want, that you can provide and add value to in Facebook, then don’t bother with the platform. Don’t jump on the bandwagon because bloggers, consultants and vendors hype it up. It’s OK to not do anything with Facebook. You may be in an industry where your customers just don’t evangelize your products, and it’s not worth building new experiences in social networks to boost your brand and customer loyalty.

But to be a disruptor, you also have to be willing to try things that might fail. Focusing on “adjacent possibilities” allows you to test ideas, and fail faster and cheaper, and move on. And if you keep at it, you might just find a winner that transforms your customer relationships.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Related Articles

5 Responses to “Is F-Commerce "Fail" Commerce?”

  1. Morgan says:

    Linda – Great points. I agree that social integrated into commerce is where the power really lies. I was in charge of “social product” at my last job, which lay at the nexus of social networks and our product. My job was to figure out integrations that grew the business while making the user experience more social and more connected to existing socnets. Ticketmaster is a brilliant example of this. KLM’s Facebook integration for picking your seat mate is another great example.

    But I don’t believe that commerce _on_ Facebook is dead by any means. In fact, I believe that the failure has to be placed at the foot of the retailers. If you’ve used a Facebook store you know the user experience is terrible. The sites are little more than product catalogs jammed into the Facebook chrome. No one should be mistaking these v1 stores as the pinnacle of commerce on Facebook – far from it.

    I believe that retailers need to get smarter about leveraging social integration on Facebook in order to make f-commerce a reality. At the same time, Facebook needs to provide greater tools and flexibility to retailers to really leverage the platform for success.

    I shared a few more thoughts on the matter here, where I delve more into possible extensions and ways that f-commerce can work in the future:

  2. Subhash says:

    “It’s not that F-Commerce is a failure, rather the shift is towards bringing social features from Facebook to your commercial website, rather than bringing your store into the social network.”

    I completely agree with your observation above.

    The emphasis should definitely shift away from “commerce”. We need to spend time and effort understanding how our target audience / customers use the new social tools. How we in turn can make use of these social networks to enhance customer experience on our e-commerce stores.
    I had placed my bets on loyalty program, a community of loyal customers, taking off in a big way on Facebook ( However, I haven’t yet seen many such attempts thus far.


  3. Paul says:

    Smart words Linda, couldn’t agree more; simply adding e-commerce apps to a Facebook page to port in e-commerce sites is pointless. Commented on your post in full
    over at Social Commerce Today.

  4. Alvin Tan says:

    We have written more than once on this, especially on the “porting social to commerce vs. porting commerce to social” debate. Hope you guys will find these articles relevant:




Leave a Reply

© 2014 Get Elastic Ecommerce Blog. All rights reserved. Site Admin · Entries RSS · Comments RSS